The revelation of Josh Weinstein’s new girlfriend has been met with skepticism from ’90 Day Fiancé’ viewers, many of whom believe Jenn Potthast is only romantically involved with him to gain further television exposure.
As previously reported by Monsters and Critics, Jenn’s identity was revealed in a spoiler for Monday’s upcoming fourth part of the ’90 Day: The Last Resort’ Season 2 Tell All. Following Josh’s split from Natalie Mordovtseva during the retreat, he announced he was seeing someone new.
That «someone» turned out to be Jenn Potthast, a familiar face within the ’90 Day Fiancé’ franchise and the sister of ’90 Day Fiancé’ star Elizabeth Potthast. However, before the official reveal, eagle-eyed fans had already pieced together the potential relationship after spotting Jenn and Josh spending time together on social media following Josh’s hints about dating someone from the ’90 Day’ universe.
In the latest preview clip from Monday’s Tell All episode, Jenn makes a virtual appearance on stage. A portion of the clip was shared on Instagram by @90daysherry, featuring text overlay that read, «[Cringe] Josh is dating who???»
Many ’90 Day: The Last Resort’ viewers are unconvinced by Jenn and Josh’s budding romance. The caption on @90daysherry’s post read, «Unless its Girl Scout cookies, Im not buying it!»
Fellow ’90 Day Fiancé’ bloggers and viewers flocked to the comments section, echoing the sentiment that the relationship seemed inauthentic. «@my_90daymafs_realitea» commented, «She is trying to get in the 90day pocketbook,» and further added, «I just can’t believe that girl would date him. It’s just another TLC stunt to get on another 90day show.» Another Instagram user simply wrote, «Oh come on..»
Adding to the cynicism, some viewers also believe that Josh’s previous relationship with Natalie Mordovtseva was also a fabricated storyline for publicity, with critics suggesting the modeling agency CEO used Natalie for «TV time.»
The unconventional pairing of Josh and Natalie on ’90 Day: The Last Resort’, a show initially intended for married couples, had already raised eyebrows among viewers.
During their Tell All spoiler interaction, Jenn and Josh played coy when questioned about the intimacy of their relationship, claiming they had been dating for a couple of months but had not yet been intimate. Josh initially dodged the question before admitting «No» when pressed further by castmate Julia Trubkina.
According to Josh, he and Jenn had already taken some trips together and had more planned, including a visit to Las Vegas. «Yeah, we’re having fun, and like, if he didn’t make me happy right now, I’d be like, ‘Bye,'» Jenn stated. When Florian Sukaj asked Jenn to rate her happiness with Josh on a scale of one to 10, she enthusiastically replied, «Right now, a 10.»
Intriguingly, Josh and Jenn were linked as far back as 2023, sparking initial speculation among ’90 Day Fiancé’ fans. As Monsters and Critics previously reported, Josh tagged Jenn in an Instagram Story from a bar, where Jenn was seen making a kissy face over his shoulder.
With this history and the current Tell All reveal, the question remains: are Josh and Jenn genuinely finding love, or are they simply playing with ’90 Day Fiancé’ fans for more screen time? Only time will tell if their connection is authentic or another calculated move within the reality television landscape.