At age 55 on May 19, 2025, at his home in Greencastle, Indiana, after battling stage 4 stomach cancer. He was diagnosed with the disease late in 2024, and sources indicate he was too weak to undergo chemotherapy. His wife, Mahogany Roca, whom he met on the show and later married, was reportedly by his side during his final moments, along with family members.
There have been conflicting reports about the type of cancer, with some sources mentioning pancreatic cancer or cirrhosis of the liver alongside stomach cancer, but the majority confirm stage 4 stomach cancer (metastatic adenocarcinoma) as the cause of death. Additionally, some skepticism arose among fans due to Rathbun’s recent legal troubles, including an arrest in November 2024 for unpaid child support and felony embezzlement charges, with some speculating the cancer diagnosis was exaggerated or fabricated. However, his passing has been widely confirmed by reputable sources like TMZ and Daily Mail.
This is a developing story, and while the reports seem consistent, some details about his medical condition remain unclear or disputed. My thoughts are with his family and loved ones during this difficult time.