The gloves are off in Montreal’s goaltending debate, and BPM Sports analysts aren’t pulling punches. On this morning’s broadcast, Anthony Marcotte and Gilbert Delorme delivered a scathing critique of Samuel Montembeault’s performance against the New York Rangers, igniting a firestorm among fans and insiders.
“It’s the elephant in the room. Monty didn’t get the job done. The third goal should never happen in the NHL… it shouldn’t even happen in the QMJHL.” — Anthony Marcotte, BPM Sports
Marcotte’s blunt assessment echoes growing frustration with Montembeault’s shaky start to the season. With a 2-2 record, a goals-against average of 3.26, and a save percentage of just .857, the numbers are hard to defend—and the patience of analysts and fans alike is wearing thin.
Dobes Rising Gilbert Delorme added fuel to the fire, suggesting that Jakub Dobes could seize the number one spot if he performs well tonight against the Sabres.
“If Dobes plays well tonight, he should play again Wednesday, and maybe even take the number one spot.” — Gilbert Delorme, BPM Sports
The Canadiens’ goaltending hierarchy is suddenly in flux. With Montembeault under fire and Dobes gaining momentum, tonight’s game could mark a turning point in the season—and perhaps in the career trajectory of both netminders.
St-Louis in the Crosshairs While head coach Martin St-Louis has publicly backed his goaltenders, the pressure is mounting. A strong showing from Dobes could force his hand, and Montembeault may find himself on the outside looking in if the trend continues.
In Montreal, nothing is guaranteed—and the spotlight is unforgiving. Tonight, the battle for the crease isn’t just about stats. It’s about survival.